Skip to main content

REVIEW: WISH

 

Walt Disney was famous for his philosophy of making films not just for children, but for the child in all of us. It's a nice tagline, for sure, but for long-time lovers of the Disney mythos, this isn't just a marketing tool. It is the dividing line between that commercial-fare that oversaturates animation as an artform and the legendary storytelling that Disney has come to define itself by. And it is the measurement against which all Disney enthusiasts weigh each new offering from the sorcerer's workshop. 

Yet Disney's newest offering, which presents itself as a tribute to the studio's 100 year legacy, plays more like a film made for children. The film is not without magic or wisdom, I would be remiss to not acknowledge that I did tear up no less than three times, but for Walt Disney Animation's centennial capstone, viewers would be better directed to something like their short, Once Upon a Studio, which traffics in similar Disney-specific shorthand yet achieves much greater emotional depth in a fraction of the runtime.

In Disney's centennial film, the act of wishing itself is the center of the plot. The kingdom of Rosas calls dreamers from all around the world to offer their deepest wish, personified as a glowing blue orb, to King Magnifico, who promises to not only keep them safe, but to actually grant the wishes of those he deems worthy with the use of his sorcery. For Asha, working as his apprentice is its own kind of dream come true, but when she learns that the king deliberately grants only the wishes that serve his ends, she invokes the stars themselves to help her liberate the kingdom from Magnifico's wickedness. When one such Star falls from the heavens, Asha enlists its help to return the trapped wishes to the kingdom and stop Magnifico once and for all. (For context, yes, we are meant to believe that this is the same Star that Snow White, Tiana, and many others will one day wish upon, but the film doesn't close out with a montage from the Disney library. Though students of the Disney canon may still be compelled to stay through the end credits just the same.)

The problem at the root of the film is that it builds its foundation on contrivance. And I don't mean the flimsiness of the magic system or the worldbuilding (though I was left with some questions about that as well), but the contrivances of the characters. When a fairy-tale asks me to suspend my disbelief, it's usually because I am called to accept that a noble thief might rescue a Genie from a Cave of Wonders or that a mermaid princess might dream of walking on land. Such premises are fantastical, yes, but they stem naturally from truths about the human heart. 

Wish is the first fairy-tale that asks me to just believe that a king would ever demand that all his citizens give him their deepest desires, and these people, knowing that they won't even remember what they wished for, would not raise any eyebrows. We are meant to believe that there are thousands of people in this kingdom and, by his own admission, the king only grants about a dozen a year, and yet they are all taken aback by the revelation that this king is in fact hoarding their wishes. (And I suppose there is an earnest question buried somewhere in there about just how complicit people can be in unjust power structures, or how they sycophantically follow charismatic but corrupt leaders, but the film doesn't reach for such profundity, even through the magic of metaphor.) Too much of the plot hinges on character motivations that don't feel honest to the realities of human behavior.

Make no mistake, Wish is still earnest and will still touch the viewer that lets themselves be vulnerable. But it reaches for the mouthfeel of a Disney classic without letting the ingredients cook. The animation, for example, is fluid, clean, and sparkling. Likewise, the musical numbers are dazzling to behold and might make for great background music in a Disneyland parade, and kudos to Ariana Debose for featuring in nearly every number in the soundtrack. 

Just so, few of the greats from the Disney songbook rely so heavily on repetition (and when they do, the lyrics they're echoing are more imaginative than "that's a lie, lie, lie, lie"). In the best musicals, in and out of Disney, song is the space where the characters share the things they don't know how to express through spoken word. But the songs in Wish never transport the viewer, emotionally or otherwise. They just repeat what we already know in case you weren't paying attention.

For the studied Disney fan, the lingering fear tends to be the potential loss of a certain sincerity in their animated output. (To its credit, while the film does make some internal shoutouts to other Disney films like Zootopia and Peter Pan, the film actually refrains from the metatextual commentary or intentional lamp shading that's intruded on the Disney lineup for too long.) The film never treads far from that ripe emotionality that animation lends itself to so naturally. But one thing we can take from the lesson of Wish is a reminder that the best of Disney has never floated on sentimentality alone, and it is okay to ask for more.

        --The Professor

Comments

  1. You make a great point about the soundtrack for this one. I haven't seen the movie, but I've listened to some of the songs. Disney has had a history of creating memorable music; soundtracks that had staying power. Not this one, however! It's almost like everyone skilled was working on another project, so they had my 3-year-old grandson, Alonzo, write the music for this one. A bit dissapointing.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What Does the World Owe Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs?

             When I say “first animated feature-film” what comes to mind?             If you’ve been paying attention to any channel of pop culture, and even whether or not you are on board with the Disney mythology, then you know that Walt Disney’s Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs was the first ever full-length animated film. (Kinda. The Adventures of Prince Achmed made use of paper-puppetry way back in 1926, but that wasn’t quite the trendsetter that “Snow White” was.) You might even know about all the newspapers calling the film “Disney’s folly” or even specific anecdotes like that there somewhere around fifty different proposed names for the seven dwarfs (#justiceforGassy).  DC League of Super-Pets (2022)           But in popular discourse, l ots of people will discuss Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs as little more than a necessary icebreake...

REVIEW: ONWARD

     The Walt Disney Company as a whole seems to be in constant danger of being overtaken by its own cannibalistic tendency--cashing in on the successes of their past hits at the expense of creating the kinds of stories that merited these reimaginings to begin with. Pixar, coming fresh off a decade marked by a deluge of sequels, is certainly susceptible to this pattern as well. Though movies like Inside Out and Coco have helped breathe necessary life into the studio, audiences invested in the creative lifeblood of the studio should take note when an opportunity comes for either Disney or Pixar animation to flex their creative muscles. This year we'll have three such opportunities between the two studios. [EDIT: Okay, maybe not. Thanks, Corona.] The first of these, ONWARD directed by Dan Scanlon, opens this weekend and paints a hopeful picture of a future where Pixar allows empathetic and novel storytelling to guide its output.      The film imag...

REVIEW: Snow White

     Here's a story:       When developing Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs , one of the hardest scenes to nail was the sequence in which the young princess is out in the meadow and she sees a lost bird who has been separated from its family. As she goes to console it, The Huntsman starts toward her, intent to fulfill The Evil Queen's orders to kill the princess and bring back her heart. The animators turned over every stone trying to figure out how to pull off this episode. They went back and forth about how slow he would creep up on her. When would he bring out the knife? When would the shadow fall on her? One of the animators reportedly asked at one point, "But won't she get hurt?"       That was the moment when Walt's team knew they had succeeded at their base directive to create pathos and integrity within the form of animation--to get audiences to care about a cartoon, such that they would worry that this tender-hearted girl wa...

PROFESSOR'S PICKS: 25 Most Essential Movies of the Century

       "Best." "Favorite." "Awesomest." I spent a while trying to land on which adjective best suited the purposes of this list. After all, the methods and criteria with which we measure goodness in film vary wildly. "Favorite" is different than "Best," but I would never put a movie under "Best" that I don't at least like. And any film critic will tell you that their favorite films are inevitably also the best films anyways ...      But here at the quarter-century mark, I wanted to give  some  kind of space to reflect on which films are really deserving of celebration. Which films ought to be discussed as classics in the years ahead. So ... let's just say these are the films of the 21st century that I want future champions of the film world--critics and craftsmen--to be familiar with.  Sian Hader directing the cast of  CODA (2021)     There are a billion or so ways to measure a film's merit--its technical perfectio...

REVIEW: The Electric State

     It's out with the 80s and into the 90s for Stranger Things alum Millie Bobby Brown.       In a post-apocalyptic 1990s, Michelle is wilting under the neglectful care of her foster father while brooding over the death of her family, including her genius younger brother. It almost seems like magic when a robotic representation of her brother's favorite cartoon character shows up at her door claiming to be an avatar for her long-lost brother. Her adventure to find him will take her deep into the quarantine zone for the defeated robots and see her teaming up with an ex-soldier and a slew of discarded machines. What starts as a journey to bring her family back ends up taking her to the heart of the conflict that tore her world apart to begin with.      This is a very busy movie, and not necessarily for the wrong reasons. There is, for example, heavy discussion on using robots as a stand-in for historically marginalized groups. I'll have ...

The Paradox of The Graduate

     If you've been following my writings for long, you might know that I'm really not a fan of American Beauty . I find its depiction of domestic America scathing, reductive, and, most of all, without insight. I don't regret having dedicated an entire essay to how squirmy the film is, or that it's still one of my best-performing pieces.       But maybe, one might say, I just don't like films that critique the American dream? Maybe I think that domestic suburbia is just beyond analysis or interrogation. To that I say ... I really like  The Graduate .      I find that film's observations both more on-point and more meaningful. I think it's got great performances and witty dialogue, and it strikes the balance between drama and comedy gracefully. And I'm not alone in my assessment. The Graduate was a smash hit when it was released in 1967, landing on five or six AFI Top 100 lists in the years since.      But what's int...

REVIEW: Mickey 17

Coming into Mickey 17 having not read the source material by Edward Ashton, I can easily see why this movie spoke to the sensibilities of Bong Joon Ho, particularly in the wake of his historic Academy Award win five years ago. Published in 2022, it feels like Ashton could have been doing his Oscars homework when he conceived of the story--a sort of mashup of Parasite , Aliens , and Charlie Chaplin's Modern Times . Desperate to escape planet earth, Mickey applies for a special assignment as an "expendable," a person whose sole requirement is to perform tasks too dangerous for normal consideration--the kind that absolutely arise in an outer space voyage to colonize other planets. It is expected that Mickey expire during his line of duty, but never fear. The computer has all his data and can simply reproduce him in the lab the next day for his next assignment. Rinse and repeat. It's a system that we are assured cannot fail ... until of course it does.  I'll admit my ...

Hating Disney Princesses Has Never Been Feminist pt. 1

     Because the consumption of art, even in a capitalist society, is such a personal experience, it can be difficult to quantify exactly how an individual interprets and internalizes the films they are participating in.      We filter our artistic interpretations through our own personal biases and viewpoints, and this can sometimes lead to a person or groups assigning a reading to a work that the author did not design and may not even accurately reflect the nature of the work they are interacting with (e.g. the alt-right seeing Mel Brooks’ The Producers as somehow affirming their disregard for political correctness when the film is very much lampooning bigotry and Nazis specifically). We often learn as much or more about a culture by the way they react to a piece of media as we do from the media itself. Anyways, you know where this is going. Let’s talk about Disney Princesses. Pinning down exactly when Disney Princesses entered the picture is a hard thi...

REVIEW: Ezra

     I actually had a conversation with a colleague some weeks ago about the movie, Rain Man , a thoughtful drama from thirty years ago that helped catapult widespread interest in the subject of autism and neurodivergence. We took a mutual delight in how the film opened doors and allowed for greater in-depth study for an underrepresented segment of the community ... while also acknowledging that, having now opened those very doors, it is easy to see where Rain Man 's representation couldn't help but distort and sensationalize the community it aimed to champion. And I now want to find this guy again and see what he has to say about Tony Goldwyn's new movie, Ezra .       The movie sees standup comedian and divorced dad, Max (Bobby Cannavale), at a crossroads with how to raise his autistic son, the titular Ezra (William Fitzgerald), with his ex-wife, Jenna (Rose Byrne). As Jenna pushes to give Ezra more specialized attention, like pulling him out of publ...

REVIEW: A Quiet Place Part II

  It must have been early 2020 when post-production wrapped on John Krasinski's A Quiet Place part II , a film that opens in flashback as we see a community descend in real-time into global mayhem. We see the Abbot family in their final moments of naive bliss before the alien monsters lay waste to the human population. Had this movie premiered in theaters on its original release date last spring, this overture might have been just a clever segue between this film and its wildly successful 2018 predecessor.  But for this weekend's audience, many of which are returning to the theater for the first time since the pandemic eradicated public living, this scene is just short of traumatizing, a mirror to how rapidly our own sense of social equilibrium unraveled before our eyes. How naive, indeed, we were to underestimate the fragility of the social fabric that permits such frivolous pastime as ritual theatergoing. The narrative proper begins minutes after the conclusion of the first ...