PROFESSOR'S PICKS: 7 Best Songs Written for (Non-Musical) Film

This being a blog about film, I generally keep my observations focused on movies, but today we're going to expand the menu just a little.

Most of the stuff I write here, I write with some film music playing in the background, usually a film score or a Broadway cast recording (right now I'm on a bit of a Raul Esparza kick, everyone deserves to hear his rendition of "Come to Your Senses" from this year's Miscast concert). I've been doing this for a while, yet I only recently had the idea to actually write about some of the songs that inform my writing process. The songs I can never get out of my head.

To keep things mostly on-brand, I'm going to be writing about music that features in films, preferably songs written for their respective movies. Just to make things interesting (and to keep the door open for a future installment ... maybe) I'm choosing to restrict the songs listed here to those written for non-musical films, and I'm choosing to define "musicals" as films that have spontaneous singing within the narrative. So for the intents of this piece, I'm not counting movies like "A Star is Born" as musicals.

We'll start with probably the most famous track on this list.

1. "My Heart Will Go On" - Titanic

This song famously plays over the end credits over James Cameron's Titanic, an epic love story set against the backdrop of the tragic sinking of the RMS Titanic. Like the film it crowns, the song strikes emotions that are both powerful and tender. Like most anything that reaches popular terminal velocity, the song's legacy has been somewhat sullied by the parody that inevitably follows overexposure. Just so, anytime I can get myself to look past the zeitgeist and see the song itself, I can't help but be blown away by the song's power.

Most of the parties involved were hesitant about making the song to begin with. Cameron himself couldn't imagine playing a song over the credits of such an emotionally harrowing film. "Could you imagine a pop song during the credits for Schindler's List?" But James Horner wrote the song in secret with Will Jennings providing the lyrics. Even performer Celine Dion took some convincing, as she didn't want to be known for only singing movie theme songs. Horner reportedly hid the demo from Cameron until he was sure the notoriously volatile filmmaker was in a good mood, and the rest is history. For a song that nobody wanted to make, it's hard to imagine an ending to the film that doesn't immediately sweep us into the embrace of the song's heavenly opening notes.

2. "Halfway Home" - The Earthling

This lesser-known gem of Australian cinema sees William Holden playing a loner, Patrick Foley, afflicted with terminal cancer. Hoping to live out the last of his days in peaceful solitude, he disappears into the wilderness of the Australian outback. But this plan is complicated when a husband and wife vacationing in the outback tumble from a cliff, leaving their young son, Sean, stranded in the outback. Suddenly, Foley is Sean's only chance for survival. Against his nature, Foley takes the kid under his wing. In opening his heart, Foley discovers something he hadn't known in a long time: love.

I'm deliberately showcasing this song directly after "My Heart Will Go On." We have libraries full of romantic ballads, and female friendship has "Wind Beneath My Wings." Where are the songs that give space for the love that two men can have for one another? You can probably find them if you dig (I mean ... there's the completely incidental "If I Didn't Have You" from Monsters Inc), but there aren't nearly as many to go around.

3. "You Are What Love Means to Me" - Tender Mercies

The film follows Robert Duvall playing a former country singer, Mac Sledge, trying to piece his life back together after alcoholism has ruined both his career and his marriage. Mac finds love again with a widow named Rosa Lee and her young son. Despite Mac's transformation, the film almost ends on a sad note. Even after putting his life back together, Mac's daughter from his first marriage, with whom he was just starting to mend a relationship, is killed in a car accident.

After a devastating funeral, Mac confesses to his Rosa Lee that he "doesn't trust happiness." After all, finding love with her and her son didn't stop him from losing his daughter. Mac's inability to ascribe meaning to his life or suffering becomes his last word in the film. In some ways, the film is nicer for not trying to dismiss Mac's pain or confusion with some Oscar-winning dialogue.

Just so, it does offer the viewer something of an answer. The film ends with Mac playing ball with his stepson out in the field. Rosa Lee watches the scene unfold from the kitchen window, a voyeur to her own paradise. All the while, this song plays in the background. We see peace and happiness passing through Mac, even if he doesn't "believe" in it.

4. "Into the West" - The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King

The Lord of the Rings is one of the most epic adventure sagas in film, and yet it's strangely fitting to end the series with what I can only describe as an epic lullaby.

This is one of those songs where it works from a number of different perspectives. Maybe this is Gandalf's message to Frodo as they sail off. Maybe this is Frodo's final admonition to Sam before he says goodbye forever. (Seriously, Frodo. What a jerk move!) Or maybe the song is for us, the audience. Maybe these characters are collectively easing us back into the world offscreen with the soothing tones of a lullaby, as though this world of magic and brotherhood is the waking world, and the world off-screen the dream.

5. "The Call" - The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian

I heard this song when I saw the movie in theaters in the waning days of my own youth, and it's only from this side of adulthood that I can appreciate how this song describes maturation.

It's sometimes easier to imagine that childhood is divided from everything that comes after by a large brick wall. Once you've made the jump, the past is a forgotten land. I've come to realize that identity doesn't work that way. Maturity doesn't work that way. The transition is gradual and quiet. If there is a single moment where any of us become adults, it's not a moment most of us can discern. Because of that, we take the jump for granted. It isn't until we're far into the country of adulthood that we realize what we've lost.

I feel like with most media surrounding the passage from childhood to adulthood, there's an impulse to implore the audience to never lose sight of childlike zest for life. This song doesn't do that. This song gives childhood its due credit. Maybe childhood outlasts our own ability to screw it up or neglect it. The song assures us that the part of us we leave behind in childhood is never really out of reach. And when we're ready to give it place in our adult existence, it all comes back to us. No need to say goodbye.

I'm not wise enough to say for certain if this is actually how growing up works, but it's certainly a more novel perspective.

6. "Stand Up" - Harriet

In addition to playing the title character in the 2019 Harriet Tubman biopic, British singer and actress Cynthia Erivo wrote and performed the film's end credits number, Stand Up. We can look forward to seeing Erivo as Elphaba in the upcoming film adaptations of Wicked (as well as the Blue Fairy in Disney's Pinocchio remake.)

The song is a rousing power anthem, and Erivo carries the song with such force. The live performance at the Oscars was my favorite performance of the evening. (And this was the same ceremony that featured a legion of Elsas singing "Into the Unknown.")

7. "Moon River" - Breakfast at Tiffany's

Audrey Hepburn reportedly fought tooth and nail to keep this song in the film when executives wanted to drop it, and the world is better off for it. The song's haunting melody and poetic lyrics make it my favorite song on this list.

The film follows the blossoming romance between eccentric call-girl, Holly Golightly, and the soft-spoken aspiring author, Paul Varjak. Holly spends the entire film hiding behind her extravagance, flaunting her free spirit in a desperate attempt to convince herself and her world that she isn't bound to anything or anyone, no matter how much she wishes she could belong with Paul.

"Moon River" captures this paradox within Holly. The song speaks to a yearning for liberation and escape, yet through its inescapable romanticness, the song confesses an even deeper longing. The desire to flow down Moon River with someone you love.

_________

In film, good songs supplement the stories in which they are told while also carrying a life of their own. In some cases, a memorable song can help guide viewers to a new favorite movie--I was listening to "My Heart Will Go On" years before I was allowed to watch Titanic.

There are obviously many more worthy songs than I can write about here. Goodness, there are many more songs than I'll ever have the capacity to discover. But let this tribute suffice for a moment.

--The Professor

Honorable Mentions

"You'll Be in My Heart" - Tarzan

"Fall On Me" - The Nutcracker and the Four Realms

"Raindrops Keep Fallin' On My Head" - Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid

"I'm Still Here" - Treasure Planet

"Falling Slowly" - Once

"Never Forget" - Murder on the Orient Express

"Is That Alright?" - A Star is Born

"I See You" - Avatar

Comments

Thawing Disney's Frozen Heart

As a millennial Disney fan and film student in utero, I often thought about what it would have been like to be there when Aladdin or The Little Mermaid , or even “Snow White” or The Jungle Book , premiered to the culture. It’s one thing to grow up and realize you have a piece of film history with you here in your living room. It’s another to get to watch the culture transform as it engages for the first time with something And I have this envy for a great many cinematic works. Like, what I would give to go back to 1946 and tell those losers who dismissed It's a Wonderful Life how they had no idea what they were sleeping on. But the Disney canon’s place within the culture is also specific. Their commitment to delivering hopeful stories to an audience that believes itself beyond such frailties as faith or kindness is unparalleled, and that makes their contributions worth studying and celebrating. And so I didn’t take it for granted during that period in late 2013/early ...

REVIEW: A Quiet Place - DAY ONE

I remember back when I reviewed A Quiet Place Part II , the thing that was on my mind a world crawling out of a global pandemic. I now dive into Michael Sarnoski's newest take on the mythology with A Quiet Place: Day One having just this morning heard the news that a certain convicted felon is being granted immunity for his involvement in trying to overthrow democracy, and I am left wondering (not for the first time) what surviving in a world that already balances on borrowed time even means. This is more or less the mindset of the film's protagonist, Sam, a terminally ill cancer patient who was already done with existing well before killer aliens started dropping out from the sky. The only things she cares about in the world are her "emotional support" cat, Frodo, and getting a taste of some proper New York pizza before this cancer takes her, alien invasion or not! While the rest of the city is running off to catch the last boat off Manhattan, she just digs deeper ...

REVIEW: The Wild Robot

I think I must have known that Chris Sanders had another movie on deck, but I guess I had forgotten it was coming out so soon. For whatever reason, when I saw his name at the end of the credits for The Wild Robot , out this weekend, I was caught off guard ... and then realized that it actually explained a lot. The basic premise felt broadly reminiscent of Lilo & Stitch , and there was at least one sequence that definitely recalled How to Train Your Dragon , both of which Sanders co-directed with Dean Deblois (executive producer on this film). With his latest offering for Dreamworks, Sanders cements his position as a titan in the world of animation. The movie sees ROZ, a shipwrecked robot stranded on an island completely untouched by humans. One would think that such an Eden would be bereft of the squabbles that humans seem so happy to create, but the animals of the island revile this new intruder and put up every fence they have. The only thin...

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid: Westerns Riding off into the Sunset

In both my Les Miserables and Moulin Rouge! pieces, I made some comment about the musical as the genre that receives the least love in the modern era. I stand by that, but I acknowledge there is one other genre for which you could potentially make a similar case. I am referring of course to the western film. See, musicals at least have Disney keeping them on life support, and maybe one day we’ll get the Wicked movie Universal has been promising us for fifteen years [FUTURE EDIT: All good things, folks ]. But westerns don’t really have a place in the modern film world. Occasionally we’ll get films like No Country for Old Men, which use similar aesthetics and themes, but they are heavily modified from the gun-blazing-horseback-racing-wide-open-desert w esterns of old. Those died, oddly enough, around the same time musicals fell out of fashion. Professors Susan Kord and El...

REVIEW: Spider-Man - Brand New Day

Somewhere in the multiverse, there's an opening chord of a review where I celebrate Spiderman: Brand New Day as some kind of welcome "return to basics" for the MCU, but that's not more than partially true. This movie is a lot more straightforward than cohesive than most Marvel pics from the early stretch of the decade. Feige finally feels confident that, yes, we know that there's a multiverse, and we don't need more reminders. But this is also not a budget Marvel movie. The film still designs an elaborate fireworks show for Peter Parker to dance around. There is also definite signaling for future Marvel adventures. Sadie Sink's stealth role in this movie (a sizzling introduction into the MCU) teases the integration of a new family of superheroes set to join the ranks of The New Avengers. But these sneak peeks feel like just that, and unlike sloppier Marvel pics, they aren't made to bear the weight of the e...

My Criminal Father Surrogate: Masculinity in A Perfect World

I've been wanting to tackle the subject of "masculinity" in film for quite some time now, but I hadn't quite known how best to do that. There's a certain buzzword, "toxic masculinity," that especially elicits a lot of strong feelings from a lot of different angles. While a post-#MeToo world has exposed some very disturbing truths about the way masculinity has historically performed, I'm not here to roast 50% of the world population. Actually, I really want to talk about a man's capacity for good. Ted Lasso (2020) There’s certainly a lot of discussion to be had for newer media celebrating men for possessing attributes not historically coded as "manly." But what's even more fascinating to me are the attempts to bridge the gap between traditional masculinity and new age expectations--to reframe an older vision of manhood within our modern context. Which brings me to Clint Eastwood’s 1993 film, A Perfect World. ...

REVIEW: WICKED - For Good

I'm conflicted about how to approach this review. I know everyone has their own yellow brick road to the myth of The Wizard of Oz as a whole and the specific Broadway adaptation that brought us all here. I don't want to write this only for others who are familiar with the source material. Even so, I can't help but review this from the perspective of a fan of the Broadway show--someone who has been tracking the potential for a film adaptation since before Jon M. Chu's participation was announced for the ambitious undertaking of translating one of Broadway's most electric shows onto film. I can't help but view this from the vantage point of someone who knew just how many opportunities this had to go wrong. And it's from that vantage point that I now profess such profound relief that the gambit paid off. We truly have the " Lord of the Rings of musicals ." What Jon M. Chu and his team have done here with these two...

REVIEW: THE ODYSSEY

I spent two-thirds of Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey thinking I was watching Ridley Scott's Gladiator only to realize I was watching John Ford's The Searchers all the time. And it was largely this eleventh-hour realization that secured the film's favorable rating from me. My slowness in catching onto this may have been partially caused by me also looking beyond the mark in other ways. Even if it had been fairly telegraphed in the promotional material, I was kind of hoping that Nolan's vision for the mythological epic would unleash a proper monster parade. But Nolan doesn't appear to want to emulate Demond Davis' Clash of the Titans any more than he did with Tim Burton's Batman in his "Dark Knight" trilogy. Witches like Circe and Calypso would never be mistaken for anything adjacent to Michelle Pfieffer in Stardust . Even something like "Pirates of the Caribbean" or "Lord of the Rings" is further on the ...

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind: Do Clementine and Joel Stay Together or Not?

Maybe. The answer is maybe. Not wanting to be that guy who teases a definitive answer to a difficult question and forces you to read a ten-page essay only to cop-out with a non-committal excuse of an answer, I’m telling you up and front the answer is maybe. Though nations have long warred over this matter, the film itself does not answer once and for all whether or not Joel Barrish and Clementine Krychinzki find lasting happiness together at conclusion of the film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Min d. I cannot give a definitive answer as to whether Joel and Clementine’s love will last until the stars turn cold or just through the weekend. This essay cannot do that. What this essay can do is explore the in-text evidence the film gives for either ...

Finding Nemo: The Thing About Film Criticism ...

Film is a mysterious thing. It triggers emotional responses in the audience that are as surprising as they are all-encompassing. As a medium, film is capable of painting stunning vistas that feel like they could only come to life behind the silver screen, but many of the most arresting displays on film arise from scenes that are familiar, perhaps even mundanely so. It’s an artform built on rules and guidelines–young film students are probably familiar with principles like the rule of thirds or the Kuleshov effect–but someone tell me the rule that explains why a line like “We’ll always have Paris,” just levels you. There are parts of the film discussion that cannot be anticipated by a formula or a rulebook, and for that we should be grateful. Arrival (2016) But the thing about film–and especially film criticism–is that film critics are not soothsayers. Their means of divining the artis...

Films and Feelings

Search This Blog